Environment

Attorney General Becerra Calls Out EPA Attempt to Cut Academic Scientists from Advisory Committees

August 23, 2019
Contact: (916) 210-6000, agpressoffice@doj.ca.gov

SACRAMENTO – California Attorney General Xavier Becerra today, as part of a multistate coalition, filed an amicus brief in support of plaintiffs in Physicians for Social Responsibility v. Wheeler. In this case, plaintiffs are challenging a directive by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) that prohibits any scientist who receives EPA grant money from serving on any EPA advisory committee. In the amicus brief the states assert that the directive hampers California’s ability to protect its residents from environmental harms and would deprive scientists at the University of California conducting research on behalf of the EPA of the opportunity to participate on an EPA advisory committee. That restriction harms both the scientists and EPA.

“We’re calling out EPA’s attempt to purge independent academic scientists from EPA advisory committees and stack the deck with industry-funded representatives,” said Attorney General Becerra. “Advisory boards are strengthened by academic and government scientists who shouldn’t have to sacrifice their funding in order to participate on these committees. We applaud the scientists bringing this case to court. In California, we believe in and proudly support science.”

Advisory committees play an essential role in EPA decision-making, providing the EPA with high-level scientific guidance on both individual regulatory standards and on the EPA's overall direction. The directive undermines the integrity of the EPA decision-making process and threatens to do serious harm to our health and environment. It is forcing many of the best environmental and public health scientists in the country to choose between obtaining valuable EPA funding for their research or serving on high-impact EPA advisory committees. Many academic scientists get funding from EPA for their research and serve on these advisory committees. The EPA wrongly contends that scientists who receive grant funding from the EPA have a conflict of interest and ignores that scientists who receive funding from industry often have a substantial personal and financial interest in the work of EPA advisory committees. As a direct result of the directive, the percentage of industry-backed scientists on these committees has dramatically increased.

A copy of the brief is available here.

Attorney General Becerra Blasts Federal Proposal Undercutting Protections for Endangered Species from Harmful Pesticides

August 15, 2019
Contact: (916) 210-6000, agpressoffice@doj.ca.gov

SACRAMENTO – California Attorney General Xavier Becerra today joined a coalition of 12 attorneys general in submitting a comment letter opposing a proposal by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) that risks exposing endangered species to harmful pesticides. Under the proposal, the EPA would substantially alter the current method used to determine whether, and to what extent, a pesticide “may affect” an endangered species or critical habitat and thereby trigger the requirement to consult with federal wildlife agencies regarding pesticide impacts and mitigation measures. In the comment letter, the Attorneys General assert the proposal will allow more pesticide registrations to go forward without, among other things, being assessed by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and the National Marine Fisheries Service, which are responsible for listing and protecting endangered species.

“The Trump Administration’s proposed pesticide evaluation method recklessly threatens wildlife and our state’s natural ecosystem,” said Attorney General Becerra. “There are nearly 300 endangered species in California alone that could be put at risk by this proposal. By design, pesticides are toxic and assessing their impact should not be taken lightly. We’re urging the EPA to rescind this foolhardy proposal.” 

In the letter, the coalition argues the proposal violates the Endangered Species Act (ESA) and is arbitrary and capricious. Pesticides must be registered with the EPA before they can be used, sold, and distributed in the United States. Under the proposed changes to the evaluation method, the EPA will be able to approve pesticides without first consulting the U.S. agencies that are charged with protecting endangered species. In particular, the proposed evaluation method changes the scope and requirements for pesticide evaluation by:

  • Unlawfully redefining and limiting what species may be considered impacted by the pesticide;
  • Abandoning the prior, more precautionary approach to estimating the potential amount and location of pesticide use;
  • Excluding consideration of impacts to species where pesticide use only infringes on small percentages of their habitat;
  • Artificially limiting consideration of pesticide drifts;
  • Ignoring potential effects on species if there is uncertainty about whether they are extinct; and
  • Failing to consider impacts of species on federal lands. 

In California, the ESA is credited with the survival and recovery of endangered species such as the brown pelican, the grey wolf, and the California condor. The current pesticide evaluation method allows federal agencies to prepare biological opinions and alternatives for proposed actions affecting wildlife. Without these protections, pesticides like DDT would continue to threaten the extinction of animals such as bald eagles. Impacts to wildlife from pesticide exposure can cause acute or long-term harms like cancer, kidney and liver damage, and birth defects. Exposure can also alter an organism’s behavior, affecting its ability to survive. For example, for bees, even small levels of pesticides can result in sublethal effects that negatively influence their mobility, feeding behaviors, and navigation.

In filing the comment letter, Attorney General Becerra joins the Attorneys General of New Mexico, Maryland, Massachusetts, New Jersey, New York, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Washington, Vermont and the District of Columbia.

A copy of the letter is available here.

 

Attorney General Becerra Files Petition Challenging EPA’s Refusal to Address Dangerous Pesticide Chlorpyrifos

August 7, 2019
Contact: (916) 210-6000, agpressoffice@doj.ca.gov

Chlorpyrifos pesticide residue remains on many foods consumed by infants and children

SACRAMENTO — California Attorney General Xavier Becerra today, as part of a multistate coalition, filed a lawsuit in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit challenging the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA) refusal to make a required safety finding for the dangerous pesticide chlorpyrifos. Chlorpyrifos is a pesticide used on more than 80 food crops. Infants and children consume a wide variety of these crops and are especially susceptible to the adverse health effects caused by the pesticide, which includes neurodevelopmental delays and other problems. The states’ Ninth Circuit petition concerns EPA’s failure to take action on a proposed rule that would have prevented exposure of the public to chlorpyrifos in food.

“Parents shouldn’t have to question whether everyday fruits and vegetables will poison their children,” said Attorney General Becerra. “The EPA is egregiously sacrificing our children’s health by refusing to make a determination on this dangerous pesticide. Today we’ll hold their feet to the fire and force them to do their job.”

“Chlorpyrifos causes significant harm to our children, farm workers and vulnerable communities,” said Governor Gavin Newsom. “California is doing our part to address the harms of this pesticide — it’s time for D.C. to do theirs.”

The coalition asserts that the order denying the states’ objections by Alexandra Dunn, Assistant Administrator of the EPA – also known as the Dunn Order – should be overturned as arbitrary and capricious and unlawful. The petition states the order:

  • Violates the Federal Food, Drug and Cosmetic Act (FFCDA), which requires that the EPA ensures there is a reasonable certainty that no harm will result to infants and children from aggregate exposure to pesticide chemical residue;
  • Contains no determination of a reasonable certainty that no harm will result from exposure to residue of the pesticide, as required by the FFDCA;
  • Disregards EPA’s statutory requirement to publish a safety determination of the pesticide residue for infants and children;
  • Continues EPA’s years-long pattern of delay in addressing the hazards of chlorpyrifos; and
  • Departs from EPA’s prior determination that it could not find chlorpyrifos safe.

Attorney General Becerra called on the EPA to issue safety findings on the pesticide in June 2017. In March of the following year, the Ninth Circuit granted Attorney General Becerra’s motion to intervene in another lawsuit after the EPA reversed course on a rule that would revoke all residue levels of chlorpyrifos in food, and issued an order that left in effect the existing level without making a required finding on the pesticide’s safety.

A copy of the petition can be found here.

Attorney General Becerra Secures Ruling in Shasta County Halting Westlands Water District Involvement in Illegal Shasta Dam Project

July 31, 2019
Contact: (916) 210-6000, agpressoffice@doj.ca.gov

SACRAMENTO – California Attorney General Xavier Becerra today issued the following statement after a Superior Court granted a preliminary injunction halting Westlands Water District's participation in an unlawful project to raise the Shasta Dam: 

“The court has stopped Westlands Water District from moving forward with a project that would hurt the people and environment in our state,” said Attorney General Becerra. “Maybe others believe they’re above the law and can get away with it. But, in California, we’re prepared to prove otherwise.” 

Attorney General Becerra filed the lawsuit on May 13, 2019 to block Westlands from taking an unlawful action to assist in the planning and construction of a project to raise the height of the Shasta Dam. The project poses significant adverse effects on the free-flowing condition of the McCloud River and on its wild trout fishery, both of which have special statutory protections under the California Wild and Scenic Rivers Act. The Act prohibits any agency of the State of California, such as Westlands, from assisting or cooperating with actions to raise the Shasta Dam.

A copy of the ruling can be found here.

Attorney General Urges Congress to Pass Strong Legislation to Address Contamination from Dangerous PFAS Chemicals

July 30, 2019
Contact: (916) 210-6000, agpressoffice@doj.ca.gov

SACRAMENTO - California Attorney General Xavier Becerra, as part of a coalition of 22 attorneys general, today filed a letter in support of Congress’ efforts to pass legislation addressing the dangers of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS). In the letter, the attorneys general provide recommendations to address PFAS contamination and urge that any new law not impair states’ protection of their own communities. PFAS are a group of thousands of chemicals, including perfluorooctnoic acid (PFOA) and perfluorooctane sulfonate (PFOS), widely used on consumer products including nonstick cookware, water- and wrinkle-resistant clothing, and food packaging, as well as in firefighting foam. PFAS chemicals do not break down in the environment and as a result, these “forever chemicals” accumulate in human bodies. PFAS chemicals have been shown to cause adverse health effects including developmental defects, kidney cancer, liver damage, and impacts on the thyroid and immune system. It is estimated that 99% of Americans have detectable levels of PFAS in their bloodstream.

“Millions of products are tainted with dangerous PFAS chemicals, which end up in the water we drink and the food we eat,” said Attorney General Becerra. “The prevalence of these chemicals means that addressing the damage they cause, and doing it quickly, is that much more crucial. We encourage Congress to pass legislation to address the dangers of PFAS and to repair the destruction these chemicals have done to our environment and the health of our communities.”

Congress is currently considering multiple pieces of legislation that address PFAS exposure/contamination issues. In the letter, the attorneys general assert that legislation to regulate PFAS chemicals should: 

  • Designate certain PFAS chemicals as “hazardous substances” under the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act (CERCLA);
  • Fund cleanups of contaminated public water systems;
  • Include PFAS in the Toxic Release Inventory, which would allow for the tracing of contamination sources and knowledge of contaminated areas;
  • Require nationwide sampling for PFAS chemicals to be conducted by the U.S. Geological Survey;
  • Ban the use and storage of firefighting foam, a known source of PFAS contamination, at U.S. military bases and any other federal facilities; and
  • Provide medical screening for PFAS exposure of firefighting personnel and members of the community who may be impacted by PFAS contamination.

Attorney General Becerra has taken continued action to protect the public from the dangers of PFAS. On June 11, 2019, Attorney General Becerra filed a comment letter opposing the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s Draft Interim Recommendations for addressing groundwater contaminated with PFAS.

Joining Attorney General Becerra in the letter are the Attorneys General of Connecticut, Delaware, District of Columbia, Guam, Hawai’i, Illinois, Iowa, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Mississippi, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, Oregon, Rhode Island, Virginia, Washington, and Wisconsin.

A copy of the letter can be found here.

Attorney General Becerra Slams EPA Attempt to Limit Clean Water Act Oversight

July 26, 2019
Contact: (916) 210-6000, agpressoffice@doj.ca.gov

SACRAMENTO – California Attorney General Xavier Becerra, leading a coalition of 14 states and the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection, today filed a comment letter denouncing the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA) guidance that attempts to roll back state involvement in the permitting of federal projects under Section 401 of the Clean Water Act. Section 401 and other provisions of the Clean Water Act preserve states’ authority to protect the quality of the waters within their borders. In the comment letter, Attorney General Becerra asserts that EPA’s guidance, which implements President Trump’s April 2019 Executive Order, is unlawful, directly contravenes both the language and intent of the Clean Water Act, and undermines state authority recognized under the Clean Water Act. 

“EPA’s guidance is yet another reckless attempt by the Trump Administration to weaken Clean Water Act protections for the nation’s waters,” said Attorney General Becerra. “California has an inherent right under the Clean Water Act to evaluate whether projects meet our water quality standards and to impose conditions on federal projects to protect our water resources. The EPA must withdraw this unlawful attempt to strip states of their authority to regulate water quality.”

The Clean Water Act reflects Congress’ policy to “recognize, preserve, and protect the primary responsibilities and rights of states to prevent, reduce, and eliminate pollution” of waters within their borders. Under Section 401 of the statute, a project requiring federal approval that may result in discharges into the waters of the United States must obtain state certification confirming that the project meets state water quality standards and other appropriate state law requirements. This certification process ensures adequate assessment of the water quality impacts of proposed federal actions and the imposition of necessary conditions to remedy these impacts. 

The multistate coalition argues that EPA’s guidance is improper. Specifically, the coalition objects to EPA’s disregard for the Clean Water Act, which provides states with a reasonable timeframe to complete the Section 401 water quality certification process. Furthermore, the group opposes EPA’s attempt to restrict the scope of states’ review of projects under Section 401 and to impose federal oversight over the states’ Section 401 decisions. The states request that EPA withdraw or revise the guidance to rectify the deficiencies identified in the comment letter.

Attorney General Becerra leads the Attorneys General of Connecticut, Maryland, Maine, Massachusetts, Minnesota, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Vermont, and Washington; and Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection in filing the comment letter.

A copy of the filed comment letter can be found here.

Attorney General Kamala D. Harris Issues Statement on Ninth Circuit Ruling in Energy Crisis Case

September 8, 2016
Contact: (916) 210-6000, agpressoffice@doj.ca.gov

LOS ANGELES -- Attorney General Kamala D. Harris issued the following statement on today’s ruling by the Ninth Circuit upholding a key decision made by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) regarding California’s energy crisis:

“I am gratified that the Court upheld FERC's determination that large energy companies, such as Shell, manipulated California's energy markets during the 2000-2001 energy crisis, leading to blackouts and exorbitant prices for the customers of California's investor owned utilities.  The decision upholds the findings on which FERC has ordered the payment of more than $200 million in damages from sellers that have not settled.  My office will continue to pursue compensation from those who gamed the market and profited from the skyrocketing prices that resulted.”

More information is available here: https://oag.ca.gov/cfs/energy and here: https://oag.ca.gov/cfs/energy/money.

Attorney General Kamala D. Harris Announces That Volkswagen Will Pay Additional $86 Million to California over Emissions “Defeat Devices”

July 6, 2016
Contact: (916) 210-6000, agpressoffice@doj.ca.gov

Civil Penalties and Significant Injunctive Terms Follow the $1.18 Billion Secured for California in Initial Landmark Settlement with Volkswagen

SAN FRANCISCO - Attorney General Kamala D. Harris today announced that, in addition to the historic $14.7 billion settlement with Volkswagen announced last week, the company will also pay California an additional $86 million in civil penalties as part of a second partial settlement over the company’s use of “defeat devices” to evade emissions testing in its diesel vehicles. 

The agreement, which is subject to court approval, represents the largest amount of money recovered by the state of California from an automaker and resolves certain aspects of the California Attorney General’s claims against Volkswagen under California’s Unfair Competition Law as well as the Dodd-Frank Consumer Financial Protection Act of 2010.  Volkswagen will also agree to significant injunctive terms to deter future misconduct, including a new requirement that Volkswagen contractors and employees report to the California Attorney General’s office any request for or use of “defeat devices.”  

Of the $86 million in penalties, the Attorney General will direct $10 million in grants to local government agencies or academic institutions to research and develop technology to detect “defeat devices” and better assess on-road emissions, as well as to monitor, model, and mitigate the environmental and public health impacts of vehicle emissions, especially on children and other vulnerable populations.

“We must conserve and protect our environment for future generations and deliver swift and certain consequences to those who break the law and pollute our air.  Volkswagen tricked consumers seeking to purchase an eco-friendly car by misleading the public about the level of harmful pollutants their so-called ‘clean diesel’ vehicles were emitting,” said Attorney General Harris.  “This additional settlement sends an unequivocal message to Volkswagen and any other automaker that California will aggressively enforce our robust consumer and environmental protection laws.” 

Today’s announcement follows last Tuesday’s joint announcement by California Attorney General Kamala Harris and California Air Resources Board Chair Mary Nichols that California, alongside the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and U.S. Department of Justice, had negotiated a landmark $14.7 billion settlement with Volkswagen over the software it installed in its diesel cars to trick emissions testing while actually emitting up to 40 times the level of harmful nitrogen oxides allowed under state and federal law. 

As part of that $14.7 billion agreement, Volkswagen agreed to spend an estimated $10 billion to compensate consumers and buy back or modify hundreds of thousands of its polluting cars, pay $2.7 billion into a trust fund for environmental mitigation projects, and spend $2 billion over 10 years on zero-emission technology.  Of the $4.7 billion in mitigation funding and investments, $1.18 billion will come to California ($800 million in zero-emissions technology investments and $380 million for environmental mitigation projects in the state).

The partial settlement announced today relates to Volkswagen’s 2.0 and 3.0 liter vehicles that deployed “defeat devices” to deceive regulators and consumers about levels of harmful emissions.  An estimated 86,000 2.0 and 3.0 liter vehicles were sold or leased in California between 2009 and 2015.  Today’s settlement preserves California’s potential criminal claims and claims for additional civil penalties and injunctive relief under state environmental laws, as well as the Attorney General’s claims for consumer relief and environmental mitigation related to the 3.0 liter vehicles.

In addition to the $86 million in civil penalties, Volkswagen agrees to strict injunctive terms as part of the settlement, including:

  • Prohibitions on false and deceptive advertising
  • Affirmatively disclosing defeat devices in certification applications and other submissions to the California Air Resources Board (CARB)
  • Notifying the California Attorney General’s office and CARB of whistleblower and other complaints
  • Requiring Volkswagen contractors and employees who are designing engine control units or engine control software to report to the California Attorney General’s office and to CARB any request for or use of defeat devices, and to keep accurate records of software features and changes that could be used as defeat devices
  • Provide the California Attorney General’s office with reports of any violations, along with periodic reports regarding its efforts to implement the injunction and effectiveness of those efforts

The consent decree was filed today in U.S. District Court, Northern District of California and is attached to the online version of this news release at www.oag.ca.gov/news.

Attorney General Kamala D. Harris, California Air Resources Board Announce $14.7 Billion Agreement Holding Volkswagen Accountable for Its Use of Diesel Emissions “Defeat Devices”

June 27, 2016
Contact: (916) 210-6000, agpressoffice@doj.ca.gov

SAN FRANCISCO - Attorney General Kamala D. Harris and the California Air Resources Board (CARB) today announced a landmark $14.7 billion national settlement with Volkswagen over allegations that the company violated environmental and consumer protection laws by installing “defeat device” software to bypass emissions controls in its 2.0 liter diesel vehicles.

As part of the national agreement, which is subject to approval by the court, Volkswagen will spend approximately $10 billion to buy back or modify these vehicles, as well as pay $2.7 billion into a trust to support environmental programs and reduce emissions and an additional $2 billion on investments and promotion of zero emissions vehicles.  The agreement preserves the Attorney General’s and CARB’s claims for civil penalties and prospective injunctive relief, as well as their claims related to 3.0 liter diesel vehicles.

In addition to providing consumer relief funding, California will receive $1.18 billion, representing more than one-quarter of the funding VW must provide for environmental projects in states injured by the company's conduct and investments it must make in zero emission technology.

“Our state and national environmental protection laws exist to protect public health and to preserve our planet for future generations.  Volkswagen undermined these objectives by deceiving California consumers and flagrantly violating California environmental and consumer protection laws by manipulating its diesel vehicles to produce false results when undergoing emissions testing,” said Attorney General Kamala Harris. “This landmark agreement not only ensures that consumers who were deceived are fairly compensated, but also requires Volkswagen to make unprecedented investments in protecting our environment and advancing zero emission technology.”

As part of the agreement, VW will offer compensation to those who own or lease a VW or Audi 2.0 liter vehicle as of September 18, 2015.  Owners have the option of having Volkswagen buy back their vehicle or, if approved by CARB and EPA, having VW modify their vehicle to reduce its emissions.  Owners who opt for a buyback or modification will also receive an additional cash payment of at least $5,100.  Some owners may receive as much as $10,000.

In addition to consumer relief and getting polluting cars off the road via the buyback and modification program, which is anticipated to cost Volkswagen over $10 billion, Volkswagen is also required to pay $2.7 billion into a trust to support environmental programs throughout the country to reduce emissions. CARB will receive and direct 14.12%, $380 million, of these trust funds to fund environmental mitigation projects in California.  Volkswagen is also required to buy back, modify, or scrap at least 85% of the subject vehicles nationally and in California, and it is required to pay for additional mitigation projects if it falls short of that requirement.   

Volkswagen must also spend $2 billion over a 10-year period to promote zero emissions vehicles through educational information, research and development, and infrastructure development (such as building charging stations), to further mitigate emissions and help right the market that was manipulated by the false emissions results in Volkswagen diesel vehicles.  Forty percent, or $800 million, of these investments will be made in California, pursuant to investment plans that will be subject to approval by CARB.

“This is a good deal for California’s environment and for California consumers. It will bring over a billion dollars of projects to California to supercharge our expanding zero-emission vehicle market, and fully mitigate the environmental harm to our air as a result of VW’s cheating,” said CARB Chair Mary D. Nichols. “The Consent Decree also recognizes the crucial contribution the dogged engineers in CARB’s testing lab played in exposing the illegal device in the first place – and the exceptionally costly and difficult challenges we face in our fight for cleaner air in a state where tens of millions breathe the most heavily polluted air in the nation.”

Volkswagen programmed software in its diesel cars to achieve lower emissions while undergoing testing, but in normal driving conditions, their cars were emitting up to 40 times more harmful nitrogen oxides than allowed by state and federal law. 

The parties settling claims against Volkswagen in this major agreement include the California Attorney General’s Office, CARB, the U.S. Department of Justice, and the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA).

California is uniquely affected, not only because of our robust environmental protection laws and CARB’s unique enforcement and regulatory role, but also because our state has the largest number of affected consumers.

In conjunction with the consent decree, the California Attorney General’s office filed a joint complaint with CARB in the Northern District of California this morning.  The complaint is attached to the online version of this news release at www.oag.ca.gov/news.

The agreement is subject to approval by the court following a public comment period.

The agreement is specific to 2.0 liter vehicles and does not include Volkswagen and Audi 3.0 liter vehicles that are alleged to have similar defeat devices installed.  It also preserves the ability of the Attorney General, CARB, and the EPA to seek civil penalties and further injunctive relief.

AttachmentSize
PDF icon VW Complaint (conformed).pdf456.18 KB

Attorney General Kamala D. Harris Releases Statement on Bipartisan Passage in Congress of Toxic Substance Control Act that Preserves Critical California Environmental Protections

June 22, 2016
Contact: (916) 210-6000, agpressoffice@doj.ca.gov

SAN FRANCISCO - Attorney General Kamala D. Harris today released the following statement, after the bipartisan passage of the Frank R. Lautenberg Chemical Safety for the 21st Century Act in the U.S. Congress, reforming the Toxic Substances Control Act of 1976 (TSCA) to limit the number of dangerous chemicals in our environment.

“California leads the nation in protecting our air, water, and public health, and has taken bold steps to guard against the unsafe presence of toxic chemicals in our state. I applaud Congress’ bipartisan effort to update and reform the long-standing Toxic Substances Control Act and thank Senator Barbara Boxer for her advocacy to protect California’s public health and environment.”

The Act significantly expands the number of registered industrial chemicals that are subject to federal regulation. The passage of TSCA in 1976 grandfathered more than 80,000 chemicals available in the U.S., allowing their continued use without the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) testing them for their affect on human health and the environment. In the absence of effective federal action, states like California stepped up to fill the void, protecting the public from highly toxic chemicals like flame retardants and emissions from industrial products.

In January, Attorney General Harris and 11 other state Attorneys General sent a letter urging Congress to limit preemption of state authority to regulate harmful chemicals, and noted the complementary roles played by states and the federal government in protecting people from toxic substances. The letter outlined seven key state principles to serve as guidelines for refining the final legislation.

The final version of the TSCA reform legislation eliminates or scales back nearly all the aspects of preemption to which Attorney General Harris and other Attorneys General objected, providing a path for states to continue to innovate, lead, work cooperatively with U.S. EPA and even enact restrictions that are more protective than the federal government’s efforts.

In particular, the final bill reflects five important principles outlined by Attorney General Harris and the coalition of Attorneys General:

  • Once EPA has taken action on a chemical, the scope of state law preempted will be no broader than the scope of EPA’s action.  This means that if EPA acts with respect to a chemical based on a cancer risk, for example, states will not be precluded from acting as to that same chemical based on respiratory risk;
  • States are not preempted from continuing to establish requirements on chemicals pursuant to longstanding state laws;
  • States may continue to enforce existing state chemical restrictions;
  • States may retain their role as co-enforcers of EPA regulations, retaining the authority to adopt and enforce identical limitations on chemicals as those adopted by EPA; and
  • State laws related to water quality, air quality and waste treatment and disposal are not preempted.

The letter was signed by Attorney General Harris and the Attorneys General of Hawaii, Iowa, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New York, Oregon, Rhode Island, Vermont and Washington.

Since June 2013, when the most recent legislative push to reform TSCA began, Attorney General Harris has been actively advocating for reform that strengthens EPA’s authority, while also preserving states’ important role.  Attorney General Harris will continue to work with other state Attorneys General and with the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency in its new role to regulate harmful and toxic chemicals.